[Int-koordination] Andersdotter: Julia Reda is knowingly out of the sync with the Pirate movement

[Jens Stomber <jens.stomber AT piratenpartei.de>]

Hallo zusammen,

Amelia hat jetzt auf meine Nachfrage hin noch einmal nachgelegt. Insb. wirft 
sie Julia vor losgelöst von der Piratenbewegung zu agieren weil Julia mit 
Ihrem Entwurf vom gemeinsamen europäischen Wahlprogramm abweicht.

Die Diskussion mit Andersdotter läuft übrigens auf der offenen pp-eu 
Mailingliste, auf der sich jeder registrieren kann:
http://lists.pp-international.net/listinfo/pp-eu


-- 
Jens Stomber - Pirate Party Germany
http://wiki.piratenpartei.de/Benutzer:ZombB
mobile: +49-151-54828237 \o\ zrtp: zombb AT ostel.co
e-mail: jens.stomber AT piratenpartei.de /o/ key id: 0x6951B4FA
fingerprint: D331 9041 7DCB 4779 C0D1 FCA0 7EDE 42DB 6951 B4FA
jabber: zombb AT jabber.ccc.de \o\ twitter: @ZombBi

councillor of the European Pirate Party /o/ https://europeanpirates.eu/
coordinator squad nsa-scandal \o\ http://is.gd/stopnsa

----------  Weitergeleitete Nachricht  ----------

Betreff: Re: Andersdotter: Pirate Party MEP Fails to Deliver True Copyright 
Reform
Datum: Sonntag 25 Januar 2015, 12:28:10
Von: Amelia Andersdotter <amelia.andersdotter AT piratpartiet.se>
An: Jens Stomber <jens.stomber AT piratenpartei.de>, pp-eu AT lists.pp-
international.net

Dear Jens,

It is my understanding that Julia has knowingly diverged from the Party
program. I advise you to reach the programme developed by the PPEU
members for the election:
https://europeanpirates.eu/common-european-election-programme

When the European Commission is better prepared to represent the
European public than Julia Reda is, I think that there is cause to be
concerned with the general fabric of European democracies. I advise you
to read the European Commission's report from the consultation which
Julia has used to gain much legitimacy:

http://ec.europa.eu/internal_market/consultations/2013/copyright-rules/docs/contributions/consultation-report_en.pdf

Unfortunately, the Reda report carries few if any of the results of the
consultation. It is written dishonestly, and the interpretation of most
of its paragraph require you to be a CJEU-case law junkie or a law PhD
to understand (either they reference case law directly, or they are made
moot by case law (such as paragraph 21), or they deal with different
legal frameworks entirely (five paragraphs).

It is my understanding that Julia Reda is knowingly out of the sync with
the Pirate movement, that additionally the European Commission /is not/,
and that Julia Reda is hindering the European Commission from stretching
their boundaries by being politically restrictive. Effectively, we are
seeing a European Commission with their hands tied because the /pirate
party/ was not able to bring itself to giving them space for reform. Our
only hope now is that MEPs with more backbone are able to re-insert
actionable space for the European Commission, but we are running the sad
risk that Monday January 20 was "peak reform", and that lobbyism will
ensure that it is all downhill from here.

best regards,

Amelia


On 01/25/15 11:33, Jens Stomber wrote:
> Dear Amelia,
>
> as the chairperson of the PPEU in my eyes you should not come up with
> statements that are not coordinated with the rest of the PPEU board, the
> council and Julias office. You as the chairperson represent the pirate
movement
> throughout Europe.
> https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Europ%C3%A4ische_Piratenpartei
>
> When you issue such statements everybody gets the impression that
Julia Reda
> is not in sync with the rest of our movement. Was this really your
intention?
>
http://torrentfreak.com/pirate-party-mep-fails-to-deliver-true-copyright-reform-150125/
>
>


-------------------------------------------------------------

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: This is a digitally signed message part.